This year marks only the fifth time since 1900 that the first night of Hannukah falls on Christmas. So this is the rare year that the hilarious the Saturday Night Live classic stop-motion animation short, “Christmastime for the Jews” doesn’t apply.
It was written/produced by legendary comedy writer Robert Smigel, evoking the look of a Rankin/Bass Christmas special, and sounding like a Phil Spector Christmas song. Here is Smigel on Bluesky, writing under his alter ego Triumph the Insult Comic Dog.
In a great oral history of “Christmastime for the Jews” by Jason Tabrys, published on Uproxx, is the story of how Smigel got Darlene Love, who sang “Christmas (Baby, Please Come Home)” on the 1963 album “A Christmas Gift for You from Phil Spector,” to sing the parody song.
Smigel: I love the A Christmas Gift For You From Phil Spector album so much. I saw Darlene Love sing at The Bottom Line, this club down by NYU in Manhattan. I think this was the early ’80s. Every year, Paul Shaffer, I think, would set it up. They would do that album, which is just all Wall Of Sound versions of Christmas classics as well as the song “Christmas (Baby, Please Come Home),” which was written for that album and which Darlene Love did on the Letterman show for 25 years. …
Darlene Love (singer): First they can’t find me and then they start calling singers to find me. This happened because one of my background singers, Elaine Caswell, works with Saturday Night Live most of the time and they happened to ask her if she might get in touch with me. She called me and asked me if she could give them my number.
Smigel: I was obviously excited to work with Darlene Love. You can tell by the end credits — the font is enormous. Her credit is gigantic. I remember Lorne Michaels making fun of me for that. I just wanted people to know we really got Darlene Love to sing it.
A couple of notes: First, I love the story about the recording of “Christmas (Baby, Please Come Home), my own favorite Christmas song. It’s said that producer Phil Spector (murderer, noted) was so thrilled with lines pianist Leon Russell was playing toward the end of the song (I was told it’s the part that starts at 2:08), he leaped out of the control room and handed Russell $100 on the spot.
And second, appearing on the same December 17, 2005 SNL show as “Christmastime for the Jews” was another comedy classsic for the ages: “Lazy Sunday,” by Lonely Island. I remember when I first watched this on my DVR, I didn’t even laugh; my jaw just dropped and when it was over, I immediately rewound so I could re-watch it, for the first time of many that day.





















